Search
× Search
Tuesday, November 19, 2024

Archived Discussions

Recent member discussions

The Algorithmic Traders' Association prides itself on providing a forum for the publication and dissemination of its members' white papers, research, reflections, works in progress, and other contributions. Please Note that archive searches and some of our members' publications are reserved for members only, so please log in or sign up to gain the most from our members' contributions.

Pair trading strategies

photo

 Ariel Silahian, Algorithmic trading systems, C#, VB.NET, VBA, c++, derivatives, forex,equities,option strategies,NinjaTrader, metatrader

 Friday, January 16, 2015

I've been trying to develop different pair trading strategies, but none of them gave me acceptable results.. couldn't get one that behaves better than a simple mean reversion strategy or even that outperforms S&P 500 Has anyone come up with a good pair strategy? It is worth to keep looking until I come up with better results? Any thoughts?


Print

15 comments on article "Pair trading strategies"

photo

 Alexander Horn, Private Investor | Entrepreneur | Market Analyst

 Sunday, January 18, 2015



Have a look here, best site I know for pair trading: https://www.pairtradinglab.com/


photo

 Asim Mahmood, Vice President at Nomura

 Monday, January 19, 2015



Which market are you looking at? I am interested in this topic and would be willing to share thoughts and ideas, we can connect offline.


photo

 Timothy Spears, Quantitative Trading Strategist

 Friday, January 23, 2015



I pairs trade stocks, mid-frequency, and initiate and close each trade with market orders. It's a lot of edge to give up, but I'm doing pretty well at it. I look at different things for trade setup than your classic pairs trader. And I look at different things for the pairs themselves.


photo

 Javed S., Director, Team Leader Energy and Utilities, Americas Research at Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ

 Sunday, January 25, 2015



http://www.tradestation.com/education/labs/analysis-concepts/market-neutral-pairs-trading


photo

 Javed S., Director, Team Leader Energy and Utilities, Americas Research at Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ

 Sunday, January 25, 2015



Pairs trading is pretty common in currency futures pairs. I know a futures trader who implementa a strategy using pairs I can introduce you to.


photo

 Javed S., Director, Team Leader Energy and Utilities, Americas Research at Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ

 Sunday, January 25, 2015



here is some good info that should be helpful:


http://www.tradestation.com/education/labs/analysis-concepts/market-neutral-pairs-trading


photo

 Larry Kase, Financial Analyst and Hedge Fund Principal

 Tuesday, January 27, 2015



Mean reversion is a fascinating subject. Sadly, identifying a useful application was elusive if not completely futile. The deal breaker was always the same; determining and measuring the time slice. As everyone knows means move. Mean reversion may occur but may happen at levels unkind to the capital account. Microsoft offers a decent example at this time. The stock dropped 10% during late session trading January 26 and early trade January 27. Means in all time slices change as a result with the shorter slice lines showing the most movement. The sharp decline drops price well below a few mean lines. Here is the problem. The mean direction starts moving south. Price can revert to the mean but that contact may happen at a price no better or below the entry as the mean slides toward price during the declining price period. It seemed that identifying movements into the distribution tails was more useful and is arguably a derivative of regression analysis. However, trading the tail was only justifiable with support from supplementary data. Basing the trade simply on tail proximity was no better than good old seat of the pants floor trading.


photo

 Rostant Ramlochan, Quantitative Equity Analyst / Strategist : Asia and US/Canada markets

 Wednesday, January 28, 2015



if you can't get a strategy to work within 1 or 2 months (even just a rapid prototype to test the concept is profitable) then you should abandon it and try something else.

there was another guy who posted in one of the groups here he hired out a big development team to build machine learning automated strategies i guess because he assumed these must be very profitable but after 2 years or futile results he decided to fire the whole development team and was thinking to start again from scratch!


photo

 Alexander Horn, Private Investor | Entrepreneur | Market Analyst

 Wednesday, January 28, 2015



We could team up and put brains together with some development on https://www.quantopian.com/ smart guys and lot of good ideas there, but have not seen any medium-term pairtrading approach there so far.. let me know if interested either here or as PM.


photo

 Ariel Silahian, Algorithmic trading systems, C#, VB.NET, VBA, c++, derivatives, forex,equities,option strategies,NinjaTrader, metatrader

 Wednesday, January 28, 2015



thanks to all for the messages...

I think that at this point I'm leaving this kind of strategy on hold. Didn't get acceptable results with pair trading.

Compared to other (very)basic strategies, pair trading is still under-performing (at least what i have so far)

So, I'm perusing new strategies for now ;)

Thanks!


photo

 Timothy Spears, Quantitative Trading Strategist

 Thursday, January 29, 2015



@Ariel,

I think that's a wise choice, because it's a crowded field with no really new insights. If you're approaching pairs trading the same way that 99.999999% of traders do, you will be disappointed in your results. There are other other profitable approaches to pairs trading, but it requires a paradigm shift in your foundational understanding of pairs.


photo

 Greg Carleu, Automated Trading Systems Development at UFA LLC

 Friday, January 30, 2015



Just saw this thread. We have been doing stat arb trading for a number of years, which is a generalization of pairs trading. It has been getting much more difficult as the field gets more crowded.

The one pointer I can give you is to not construct your pairs using correlations of historical data. This is just data mining and will lead nowhere. The pairs must have an economic underpinning and you must build your model using those economic relationships.

Good luck.


photo

 Ariel Silahian, Algorithmic trading systems, C#, VB.NET, VBA, c++, derivatives, forex,equities,option strategies,NinjaTrader, metatrader

 Friday, January 30, 2015



@Greg, I was looking for that kind of insights !

Thank you for sharing!


photo

 Andrew A., Technical Support Engineer at Biscom

 Saturday, January 31, 2015



Comparing to S&P is... interesting. Unless you're taking on similar levels of risk, comparing rewards is pretty useless, IMO. I personally like comparing my strategies more to bonds (of course, I don't completely), for the simple fact that algo strategies should primarily be low risk, and then focus on rewards. If your strategy is too volatile, then it's too "chancy" and not "systematic". Again, these are simply my opinions. I'm sure others will disagree with me.


photo

 Paulo Ribeiro, CFA, CMT, HEAD OF ISSUANCE AND MARKETS DIVISION at IGCP

 Sunday, February 1, 2015



how about intraday cointegration with triples of stocks? Anyone tried?

starting to backtest in matlab

Please login or register to post comments.

TRADING FUTURES AND OPTIONS INVOLVES SUBSTANTIAL RISK OF LOSS AND IS NOT SUITABLE FOR ALL INVESTORS
Terms Of UsePrivacy StatementCopyright 2018 Algorithmic Traders Association